Sorry if this offends but I fully agree with Tyra for giving her gifts, and on the fact of whether she deserves them or not…why not? she has worked hard for her money and I’m sure both Tyra and Jessica have done thier bit for charities etc over time.

I agree there are women out there who NEED this stuff more but whos to say if they deserve it more or not? I think Jessica should enjoy the gifts and not worry about what other people think.

I didn’t know about Cash’s ancestry. Well this child will definitely have a vey rich and diverse background – and a beautiful mother!

I agree with Magenta. You can’t get mad about one person being nice to another person. This was just one friend giving the other friend some baby gifts to welcome their first child into the world. Just b/c they have money doesn’t mean that their friends can’t give them gifts. Gracious!!! Besides, how do you even know what Tyra or Jessica donates to charity??? Maybe she will donate the gifts, or maybe either or both of them donate a lot of money to charity already — maybe they do it under the radar to avoid having self-righteous ppl make statements about them and then say they’re not giving enough or could be giving more. You never know the whole story, so you shouldn’t judge. Just let her be happy in celebrating her first pregnancy and enjoying this happy occassion.

I think this is a wondeful gesture from one friend to another. Tyra and Jessica work hard for their money. They don’t have to give anything away to charity. I hope Jessica and her new baby enjoy those gifts as much as possible. It’s not Tyra’s or Jessica’s responsibility to support pregnant-women-in-need. While stuff happens, if you know you can’t afford a baby and get pregnant anyway you should not be looking for a handout from celebrities just because “they have so much”.

Yeah, I don’t agree with Tyra on this one. Yeah, she’s still a pregnant woman and everyone deserves free stuff but we’re talking about over 20 different baby items for a woman who has done multiple movies this year!

A better way to have done this (and even for the companies to get their name out there) is to have had a show about woman who actually NEED that stuff. Woman who can’t buy their babies activity gyms and leather diaper bags because they’re focused on keeping food on the table every night. Woman who are going to work until they give birth and then be back at work ASAP because their work doesn’t have a good maternity leave plan. There are many, many woman like that out in the world. Heck, stop by a pregnancy center and you’ll find dozens.

I just think Tyra could have used her celebrity in a better way.

I’m not bashing Jessica about this at all because I don’t know what she’s going to do with the baby stuff and it really isn’t polite to tell Tyra “No” to all this nice stuff. It was thoughtful of Tyra but unnecessary, in my opinion.

yes celebbabylover they derserve gifts too, but how about ONE suprise present and maybe a donation to a childrens charity in her or even the impending babies name? not everything has to be material and its a way of giving back to the people that helped make her fortune in the first place (watching films, buying merchindise ect)…..surely she will want to pick out her own taste of furniture, pram for her firstborn anyway.

It makes me cringe seeing her get all that stuff.

Tyra could have instead given Jessica just one of the gifts and then to celebrate her pregnancy give away other baby gifts to pregnant women in the audience. All who would probably be in much greater need of them.

Natalie and Renee- ITA! Are those of you who are saying you don’t think Tyra (or the companies) should have given Jessica the gifts trying to say that celebs shouldn’t ever recieve gifts just because they’re rich?

Celebs deserve gifts just as much as us “regular” people do! And like Natalie, Renee, and some of the other commentors have pointed out, Jessica may give some, or all, of her gifts to charity, or at least to friends and/or family. Also, for all we know, Tyra or the companies that make the gifts Jessica recieved (since we don’t know for sure if it was Tyra or the companies that actually gave Jessica the gifts) also donated some money and/or products to charity as well.

Yea I found it weird someone as thin as jessica wears spanz in general, she probably just wears it now because she is pregnant. She was super tiny before the pregnancy, and didn’t need it lol. As for the gifts, I don’t care they were presents giving to her for her first baby. May she enjoy it, there are some nice stuff she got. Ellen gives a lot of baby stuff on her show too celebrities too.

Jessica Alba may donate the items or give them to friends. Don’t assume that just because you are rich that you are greedy. My friend is pregnant and wealthy–I’m talking about the top 1-2% of the population–and I give her gifts and plan to give her a shower with a registry. She also gives me lots of things for my baby and gives lots of money to charity! Don’t make assumptions!